Page 1 of 2 12 LastLast
Results 1 to 10 of 19
  1. #1
    Regular wwretched's Avatar
    Weasyl
    wwretched
    Join Date
    Jan 2014
    Location
    Texas
    Gender
    Genderqueer Demiboy
    Posts
    86

    Discussion: do you need to create something "important?"

    I've been thinking about this tumblr post explaining Miyazaki's comment for a couple of days and I want to know what you guys think about it. The post itself talks about his attitudes towards otaku and the works they create, and I'll spend less time describing the post and more time linking to it and its analysis so you can form your own opinions: http://kamen-rider-rahbito.tumblr.co...ightofsuperior

    With that said, here's what I've been thinking about. The commentator described the work that otakus create, selfish and unrealistic as opposed to Miyazaki's work which is incredibly beautiful and resonating. I believe that in twenty years down the road, Miyazaki's works will still be remembered while some self-serving "creepy" animes will be quickly forgotten and many others will take their places. In a sense, is it more important to create work that will be remembered or is it better to create work that caters to your own tastes? I don't want this to turn into a discussion about whether or not something is good or bad art but more or less what is more important to society. I've seen plenty of "good art" portraying ""bad"" subjects and vice versa. Should we create work that's going to better society? Or should we make what we want? (Though that's not to say that the two could be or should be different!) Is there anything to be gained from niche works, be they from something as simple as an AU for a TV show or extremely specific fetish works?

    Related: What do you think today's "art movement" is? It seems like today there's a lot more artists with a lot of different styles, all of which are valid and unique. Has there been anything like this in the past? (I honestly don't know, though I'm sure there have been artists who have been swept under greater movements.) What can be said about the artistic freedoms that a lot of work has today?

    I'm bad at getting my ideas out, so I hope that this comes across correctly! If you feel like I'm making a gross generalization or missing out on something that could be discussed, feel free to bring it up. I don't really have an opinion on this, so I'd love to see what you all make of it! And please, let's be civil; address the opinion, not attack the person.

    Let's get a good, respectful discussion going! I can't wait to see your opinions!
    dont even test me i swear to god im going to eat everything in this fucking state

  2. #2
    Senior Willow's Avatar
    Weasyl
    willy
    Join Date
    Nov 2012
    Location
    Illinois
    Posts
    333
    He has a point, honestly. It's kind of like if Hasbro started marketing more to appeal to what Bronies want instead of trying to appeal to both Bronies and young girls (which sounds weird on its own).

    Not to say everything has to necessarily benefit or resonate with a ton of people, but it gets so boring when everything starts to follow the same patterns or make it obvious who they're trying to cater to.

    As far as this age's art movement, there's definitely a lot of abstract things going on. Things that don't always catch your eye at first but then when you notice that one little detail it really sticks with you. I'm pretty sure there's an actual name for it but I can't think of what it is.

  3. #3
    I think i can somewhat agree, actually i stopped liking most anime after inuyasha and gundam seed, seems like everything that came out was... All the same. I totally get why it happens like willow said about marketing to x group, but it kind of ruins it you know? Sure a lot of people buy this this, thats business but its also losing out on the market of people that dont. I guess I just feel like s lot of things aren't even close to being original. I mean, his works were great and imaginative, people could relate to many of his characters not just one. I think thats what he is trying to say is the problem. Great animations, shows, stories... People can re late to the characters and that gives it meaning and makes you remember. But when it relates only to you and your group then a lot is missing.

    Like sure... That character is sooo cute.... Two days later... Omg that character is sooo cute, not hard to replace sooo cute with sooo cute. You know?

  4. #4
    Does my work have to be important? No. Does it have to be important to me? Yes. There's a clear difference between creating art based on someone else's expectations and creating art based on your own.

  5. #5
    is it more important to create work that will be remembered or is it better to create work that caters to your own tastes?
    It's a really difficult question.

    To me personally they are both equally important, as each serves a different purpose.

    If you ask many of the professors and students at the college I went to, they would argue that art created for oneself (art for arts sake) isn't really art at all.

    As far as "what is today's movement" there is no singular movement for today, and that is the same of the past several movements tend to coexist together. With those that are believed to be most influential/important being those that are talked about in text books. There are probably hundreds of movements right now, although only a handful will be remembered.
    Fish heads! Fish heads! Rolly polly fish heads! Fish heads! Fish heads! Eat them up! Yum!

  6. #6
    Some people do art to help themselves, and some people do art to help others. It's just a matter of where you fall. For me atm, I'm creating things that help me, someday Id like to create something that'll mean something to many other people.

    It isn't to say that one is more important than the other to be honest. It's whats most important to you. There are plenty of artists in the world who will make nice things but wont be remembered 20/30/50/100 years down the road and thats just fine and dandy with them. Some people want to change the world with their art, and who knows maybe they will. We as humans loose something when we loose our ability to create, so to say that making something for yourself isn't important is really dangerous. Works for yourself and works to better society are both incredibly important.
    Weasyl | DeviantART | Tumblr
    Always open for commission!

  7. #7
    Regular wwretched's Avatar
    Weasyl
    wwretched
    Join Date
    Jan 2014
    Location
    Texas
    Gender
    Genderqueer Demiboy
    Posts
    86
    Good thoughts guys!! It's really awesome reading through these and seeing what people come up with.
    dont even test me i swear to god im going to eat everything in this fucking state

  8. #8
    Personally, I'm a big fan of both art for art's sake, as well as the idea that art can (and in some cases) should evoke emotion or discussion.

    Art can be a way to draw people in via a "pretty picture" to then get them to think about something, like with politically motivated pieces (Banksy comes to mind). It can be seen as a way to provoke thought in minds of people who may otherwise not think about the issue or comment on it.

    On the other hand, I feel like dictating that all art should have a function, didactic or otherwise, is like wishing for art to be dead. Art can be appreciated for it's beauty, for the technical skill of the maker or just because. There doesn't need to be a reason of "It makes a big statement" or "It provokes discussion". Art for art's sake, pretty much. If an artists feels like he or she shouldn't pick up a brush if they can't convey a message, then they are stifling their own creativity.

    Then there's the issue of people overthinking art and making their pieces bloated with symbolism and meaning, out of this dogmatic thinking that if art does not have a message, it's not worth making.

    I feel like I should probably get myself a cup of coffee to try and formulate my ramblings so far into a coherent statement but I just can't seem to brain today.
    I hope this is still somewhat comprehensible. If not, feel free to point out what is unclear and I'll try my best to kickstart my brain and be more coherent.

  9. #9
    Senior TealMoon's Avatar
    Weasyl
    TealMoon
    Join Date
    Oct 2012
    Location
    The Internet
    Gender
    Female
    Posts
    366
    That thing about the ipad is hilarious.

  10. #10
    Senior Rinzy's Avatar
    Weasyl
    Rinzy
    Join Date
    Jan 2014
    Posts
    209
    It depends what your goals are. Are you in it to be remembered, or are you in it for the gratification of creating something entertaining and ending there?

 

 

Posting Permissions

  • You may not post new threads
  • You may not post replies
  • You may not post attachments
  • You may not edit your posts
  •